Chris,
Let me take a stab at this because I am having a hard time understanding your starting procedure. When you start your boat, your throttle (lever on the right hand side that goes forward and backward for forward and reverse), must be in the neutral (straight up) position to start. As I type this I think I figured out what you mean.......I am now going to assume you push the center button on your throttle and push it forward to get a higher idle while still in neutral. The reason I missed that was that I had an efi and I never had to prime, choke or give it any additional fuel so I never used the red button to idle it up. With a hotfoot, you don't need to do that. You leave the throttle lever straight up and use your hotfoot to give it more gas while cranking...when it's running your throttle is all done by your foot, the handle just shifts forward and reverse.
TOXIC