(From the aforementioned letter): "As you know, fish have a neurochemical system like ours and thus the brain capacity to experience fear and pain . . . Many die slowly and painfully from suffocation."
Let me just add something about the "pain" part a bit. Our Scout group works a private lake here in Missouri that receives VERY little fishing pressure (except from our group, of course). The lake is over-populated and has a lack of forage fish for the bass. As a result, the bass that do inhabit the lake tend to be malnourished (big head, small body). We initiated a slot limit so that the bass could feed on the bass fry hatched each year. It's cannibalism, but its saving the fish and they're beginning to look healthier. For this lake, a three pound fish is great. My brother-in-law hooked a nine pounder.
How much pain does a bass feel when it's STARVING to death, and expending limited energy competing for an amount of food that really doesn't replace what it expended to catch that food in the first place. How slowly does a starving bass die, when it can't find enough food to regain its strength? I'm sure its a lot more slowly than one that suffocates in an ill-maintained livewell, or one that is quickly dispatched under my electric filet knife.
How much more sick does a bass get when it is malnourished than when it is living in a lake where the number of predatory fish and the number of forage fish are balanced?
Follow PETA's logic about banning fishing, and you will end up with lakes that are out of balance.
What they really want is for all HUMANS to die (except tree-hugging, vegetarians like themselves) so that "Mother Earth" can be restored to its former glory. In other words, you and I are in the way. We're in THEIR way. Talk about compassionate?
If you want to really get into the heads of folks like this then buy, beg, borrow (but don't steal) it and read Tom Clancy's novel RAINBOW SIX. It'll make yer skin crawl.
Sorry, just had to sound off.
Mark