I think Tebow is a winner but Brady is a champion 3 times over.
As for the comparison to Elway, Montana and Stauback, I think a better comparison is to Big Ben or even Michael Vick who have had more success running than passing early in their careers. Tebow's passing isn't accurate yet to make the comparisons to these champions you mentioned just yet. Let's see how long Tebow can make it on his running and PFJ (play for Jesus) mentality before something breaks down. I like him but he has only played half a season. Let's give him a few seasons before we adorn him with all these accolades.
Keep in mind, up here in New England, we don't have many evangelicals - we believe in bad weather and the puritan notion that every day is a struggle. Certainly, it will be one later tonight and I am hoping for the best, but expecting the worst.
Go Patriots!
Bill, the MadKayaker