You should consider a new Nitro (or any of the other boats you listed) because YOU like them. I know that's not what you want to see on the board, but it's the most honest truth I can write. There will be some here that love Nitro (where's KB? :lol: ) over anything on the planet. There are followers of the others too.
I've recently looked at boats. Not because I am going to get another one anytime soon. I can't afford to right now, and mine is treating me just fine for the moment. But if you want opinions, here is what I think of the newest boats from those you listed.
Nitro - good strong boat for the money. Good ride. Decent speed. But there are some things that have me shy away from them. The quality of some of the plastic parts on the dash are one turn off. My biggest thing with Nitro has to do with the dealerships. I realize more people crawl through Nitro's and Trackers every day - more than other brands at other dealerships. But if I were running a Nitro/Tracker dealership, I'd ensure that any broken parts are fixed before the next days opening. Every time I've been at BPS lately, I see several boats with broken pieces - buttons, knobs, plastic, etc... I know it's the customers that are mistreating them, but it's a huge turn-off for me when I see that on a brand new showroom boat.
Skeeter - never liked the legroom in a Skeeter. Plus, I'm a Merc man. Last time I talked to a Skeeter rep, I got turned off by all the things that would "void my warranty". Everything I said - he replied with "Well, you could do that, but you would risk voiding your warranty." Too bad too, because they make a really nice looking boat that is well laid out.
Ranger - price tag. If I had the money - it would be no question... I'd own a Ranger - particularly the Z520. Ohhhhhh maaaaaannnnnn.... That's one awesome machine. But Ranger sure is proud of their boats. The price tags make my stomache hurt.
Champion - never seen a showroom. I've seen them on the water, and heard lots of good things about them, but I've never driven one, and to tell the truth, they always seemed kind of "plain" to me. I've heard the rough water ride was good, but I wouldn't know. I haven't driven one to see.
Bass Cat - Also expensive like the Ranger, but I could actually afford one that I looked at the last time I was in a BC showroom. I like Cat's - well laid out, nice looking rigs that perform well for their owners. I've been told that their customer service is the best, and recently I checked it out for myself as I bought some BC battery trays for my boat (only company that carried the ones I wanted). If I were to have the cash to buy a affordable, well built boat right now - it would be a BassCat.
So... if we are talking "opinions", and also "cash is no object", my choices would be:
1) Ranger Z520 (198 VX for a 19 footer)
2) Bass Cat Cougar FTD (Pantera II for a 19 footer - + 1")
3) Skeeter I20 (ZX190 for a 18'5")
4) Nitro Z9 (Z7 for a 18'7")
5) Champion ??? (Cause I don't know enough about them to make a decision on them)
Cash being an object, the choices become 2,3,1,4,5.
But then again - that is simply my likes. Don't go by what I or anyone else thinks of the boat - go check them all out for yourself. Otherwise, you might be in a new Ranger and ride in a Nitro and think "Dang it - I like this better!"... and then you will be really hurt when you go home and remind yourself of how much your monthly boat note is. :lol:
All the best,
Glenn