Uncle Billy,
If we are talking about varying the limits on each individual lake, then we are on the same page. If we are talking about saying "No matter what lake we fish on, BASS tournament pro's are limited to 20lb test - period.", then no, we are not on the same page.
Thinking about it further, I don't think I'm in agreement on a line size restriction at all. Sometimes, I'll throw heavier line than normal on in order to restrict my lure from going deeper or faster, or go lighter in order to make it go deeper or faster. Each of these has risks. The heavier line size will probably get me less bites. The thinner line size may cause me more break offs. But it's a trade off, and a decision that I make based on where and what I am fishing.
Years ago, BASS had HP restrictions set at 150hp. The result? Most everyone I knew drove 18' boats with 150hp engines on the back. It was the most popular setup available. What happened when the HP restrictions were lifted? 19',20',21', and even 22' boats became more popular. Engines started popping up everywhere with 200, 225, 250, and even 300hp. The market boomed.
Not saying the same thing will happen with fishing line, but it's a consideration if we go to a "Maximum tournament size" on our fishing line. If braid or heavier lines aren't allowed in tournaments, that type or size may diminish in popularity and therefore be dropped from the offerings from each company due to a reduction in sales volume. Then what do the people who want or need that size of line do?
Another thing to think about is this - The last remaining "size" limit that I knew of in BASS tournaments was the rod length (set at 8' for years). I'm not sure if that is even still in the rule books. But now we are discussing putting line size restrictions. What next? Number of tackle boxes? Number of crankbaits? Number of different worm colors and styles? Why all the restrictions?
How would you feel if they went the other way with this? Something that says "Due to all the popped small diameter / small lb test line that is found in the water, we are now not allowing any tournament angler to fish with any less than 20lb test." :blink: Then what would happen to your way of fishing if that line size dropped in overall popularity and was summarily dropped from the line size offerings?
My way of thinking - Fish with what you want to fish with and don't impose (or propose) restrictions on others based on what you like or feel should be used. But that is only my opinion. I understand and respect your way of thinking too, even if I don't agree with it.
All the best,
Glenn