I have a Pro Qualifer and like it quite a bit. I also have the old style Shimano Curado and a Pflueger President baitcaster. Of the three, the Shimano is tops (wished I had purchased more than one of the old style!), the Pflueger is a very close second (but $40 more than the Shimano old style) and the Pro Qualifer a closer third. That doesn't mean the Pro Qualifier is bad - just that its not as smooth overall. But I consider all of them - PQ included - to be great reels. For value, on the other hand, the PQ wins hands down. Just can't beat it for the price (IMHO). If I were to buy more baitcasters, PQ would be tops on my list for value for the money in a very good performing reel. The only real competition would have been the Shimano, but since they don't make the Curado at the $100 price point, its a moot issue.